The Living City Report Card

THE LIVING CITY® REPORT CARD 2016 A Progress Report on Environmental Sustainability in the Toronto region

OUR SHARED PATH TO ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY

The Living City® Report Card is a progress report on environmental sustainability in the Toronto region.

It looks at six themes – CARBON, AIR QUALITY, WATER, WASTELAND USE and BIODIVERSITY– and answers three important questions: How are we doing? Where have we excelled? And on what issues do we need to work even harder?

The first The Living City® Report Card was released in 2011. VIEW IT NOW.

The 2016 report card is a five-year progress report.

Change since the first The Living City® Report Card in 2011 is mixed: the Toronto region has made some important improvements, maintained past progress in other areas, and seen other indicators decline.

However, the overall picture is clear: progress toward a sustainable Toronto region is slow.

illustration of a grove of trees

The path ahead is not easy. We face many challenges: a growing population, continued urban development, and climate change.

Nevertheless, there is reason for optimism. Many individuals and organizations are undertaking great efforts to advance environmental sustainability in our region.

By thinking and acting regionally, we will make the Toronto region a cleaner, greener, and healthier place to live. Together, we can accelerate our collective impact. Together, we will achieve more.

READ THE 2016 REPORT CARD

illustration of a flower garden

ABOUT THE LIVING CITY® REPORT CARD

The Living City® Report Card 2011

Toronto and Region Conservation Authority (TRCA) and CivicAction’s Greening Greater Toronto collaborated with organizations and environmental leaders across the region to produce the first Living City® Report Card in 2011.

illustration of wildlife on the shores of a waterway

The Living City® Report Card 2016 Has Six Themes:

 

Explore The Living City® Report Card

CARBON

illustration of homes and businesses emitting carbon

Carbon dioxide is one of the primary greenhouse gases (GHGs) emitted to the atmosphere by human activities.

Burning oil, gas, coal and other fossil fuels in our power plants, factories, homes and vehicles releases GHGs. These GHGs trap heat in the atmosphere and oceans, contributing to global warming and climate change.

There is broad consensus among scientists and decision makers that climate change is the most serious environmental threat facing our planet, its ecological systems and our way of life.

Global emissions of GHGs have reached the highest levels ever measured.

illustration of cars and trucks

Transportation fuel use and natural gas consumption by homes and businesses for heat are the two largest sources of GHG emissions in the GTA.

Although we’re working hard to reduce our GHG emissions, there is still quite a bit of work to be done. Municipal leaders need to keep in tune with emerging federal and provincial policy frameworks to determine how their cities can influence, adopt and build upon these policies at the local level.

 

CARBON Our emissions are changing our climate WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? Greenhouse gases (GHGs) are released to the
atmosphere by human activities. GHGs trap
heat in the atmosphere and oceans and are
causing the climate to change.
In Ontario, we produce almost 2x the world average GHG emissions per person. WHAT'S HAPPENING? Transportation fuel use and natural gas consumption by homes and businesses for heat are the two largest sources of GHG emissions in the GTA ONTARIO eliminate coal-generated is the first jurisdiction in North America to electricity. Coal made up 25% of Ontario's
electricity generation in 2003 and
was reduced to
zero in 2014. Scientists consider climate change
the most serious environmental
threat facing our society.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Create efficient, integrated
transit
Improve electric vehicle
infrastructure

AIR QUALITY

illustration of a truck and a bus

Air pollution is responsible for significant negative health impacts.  Research has linked air pollution to a number of health concerns, including allergies, respiratory illness, cardiovascular disease, and cancer.

Even at low levels, air pollution can cause significant health impacts due to the long-term systematic exposure. These health impacts have a strong bearing on our quality of life and place an unnecessary strain on the health care system.

Over the past decade, concentrations of most common air pollutants have declined across Ontario. However, variations in air quality within a community can be as great as the variation between communities; and this variation is rarely measured.

illustration of people walking dogs and riding bicycles

We do know that when we drive our vehicles and use energy in our offices and homes, we are likely burning fossil fuels (such as gasoline, natural gas, and/or oil) and sending pollution into the air. This contributes to smog and poor air quality, which is directly linked to impacts on human health.

In order to improve air quality in the GTA, we need all levels of government to continue to encourage the development of clean industry, energy and transportation.

We also need more comprehensive and detailed local area monitoring within urban neighbourhoods to better understand how air quality is affecting people at the local level.

 

AIR QUALITY improving air quality improves our health WHAT'S HAPPENING? Burning fossil fuels such as gasoline when we drive our
vehicles sends pollution into the air, which contributes
to poor air quality.
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? Air pollution causes health effects such as
respiratory illness and cardiovascular disease
that affect our quality of life and strain the
health care system.
AIR QUALITY MONITOR Most common air pollutants
have declined across Ontario.
But these declines might not
be apparent at the local level.
Local air quality monitoring
is needed.
The number of smog days in
the GTA have decreased over
the last decade
WHAT CAN WE DO? Local air quality monitoring Improve public and active
transit infrastructure

WATER

illustration of birds in an urban wetland

Water is one of the most important substances on earth. Clean, safe water in our region’s rivers and streams and in Lake Ontario is critical to our economic, social, and environmental health.

Clean water is necessary for commercial activities such as agriculture, fishing, and manufacturing. It is also important for recreational activities such as swimming and boating.

The biodiversity of our streams and lakes depends on clean water, and so does our own health and well-being. Clean water is a precious and limited resource that should be valued and protected.

Water management is central to environmental sustainability. Despite the fact that water is a limited resource, Canadians are among the highest consumers per person in the world.

water gfx crop@2x

Poor water management in urban areas can lead to flooding, water pollution, contamination of drinking water and damage to local ecosystems.

For example, in some areas untreated and uncontrolled stormwater flows directly into streams, carrying contaminants and increasing stream flow volume and speed. This impacts the aquatic ecosystems and increases the risk of flooding in our local waterways.

Opportunities to improve water management include full-cost pricing for water to encourage water conservation, and incorporation of low impact development (LID) techniques into stormwater management.

 

FLOOD RISK A changing climate is increasing Climate change may increase the
frequency and power of unpredictable
thunderstorms, leading to more floods.
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? There are tens of thousands of people living in flood-
vulnerable areas. All rivers flood, but our rivers flood
more often because of stormwater runoff from
urban areas.
WHAT'S HAPPENING? 43 flood-vulnerable clusters in the Toronto
region (where communities existed
before modern policy that prevented
development in floodplains).
TRCA and municipalities continue to
work to prevent and mitigate
riverine flooding. The TRCA Flood
Forecasting and Warning program
is used across the Toronto region.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Plan and prepare to help
reduce the risk from flooding
Improve stormwater
management
risk in flood-prone areas

STORMWATER We need to do a better job Effective stormwater control
helps prevent flooding and
protects water quality.
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? Stormwater rushes off roofs, sidewalks and parking lots into
pipes that pour into rivers, streams and Lake Ontario. Without
proper stormwater management to detain and treat
stormwater before it enters our waterways, we risk:
WHAT'S HAPPENING? Green infrastructure is an approach to water management
that tries to mimic the natural water cycle. Green
design for stormwater control. LID filters, evaporatos, cools,
and retains stormwater runoff instead of going directly into
streams and lakes.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Invest in stormwater management
in new and existing urban areas
Develop policy that encourages green
infrastructure approaches, including LID
managing stormwater MANAGEMENT 65% of urban areas don't have modern stormwater control Flooding
Erosion
Water pollution
Damage to local ecosystems
PIPE

WATER QUALITY Clean water is essential for life The health of people, fish and animals
depends directly on the quality of water
that they live in or drink.
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? of the time in Toronto, 2015 WHAT'S HAPPENING? 88% Levels of contaminants such as
phosphorus and metals are the
same or decreasing.

Chloride, from road salt, is
increasing. E.coli bacteria
remains an issue, and
microplastics are a new threat.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Improve stormwater management and use
Low Impact Development (LID) practices
Reduce road salt use and find
safe alternatives
Stormwater runoff is caused by rainfall or snowmelt moving over the ground. chloride in streams is INCREASING As the water runs off hard surfaces, it picks up
and carries pollutants to our streams and lakes.
STREAM CHLORIDE CONCENTRATIONS 120 mg/L Canadian Water Quality Guidelines 1986-2000 2000-2015 SAFE BEACHES beaches awarded
a Blue Flag status
LID filters, evaporates, cools and retains
stormwater runoff instead of going directly into
streams. Techniques include rain gardens and
permeable pavements.

WATER CONSUMPTION Water is a valuable but limited resource High water consumption takes water away
from natural ecosystems and increases
infrastructure and energy costs for
municipalities.
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? Toronto increased WHAT'S HAPPENING? Canadians are among the highest
consumers of water per person in
the world.

In the GTA, water consumption is high
and the demand will continue to increase
due to our growing population.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Implement full cost pricing
Encourage water conservation
THE REAL COST OF WATER: Full cost pricing means
setting prices for water that include the entire cost
of pumping, cleaning and distributing, plus
environmental costs.
water prices Residential water use declined 10% 24% (per person) Our freshwater supply from Lake
Ontario is plentiful for now, but can
be jeopardized by overconsumption
and pollution.

WASTE

 

illustration of houses with recycling bins

Almost everything we do creates waste. Waste is often stored in landfills, which  produce carbon emissions, take up valuable land, and represent a wasted use of valuable materials that could have been reused, recycled, or resold.

As our population continues to grow, we will continue to create waste. Our current consumption levels are unsustainable and will impact the kind of world we will leave for future generations.

Although there have been some small gains in individual municipalities, waste management for the GTA as a whole has not improved over the past five years.

illustration of buildings with trash bags in front

Effective waste management contributes to preserving our environment and making our region more sustainable.

We need to focus our attention to the on making waste diversion a priority, particularly in multi-unit residential buildings. This includes making waste diversion easier for residents and building tenants by increasing opportunities for recycling, reduction, and reuse of materials.

 

WASTE MANAGEMENT Reduce, reuse, repair, recycle, recover WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? Effective waste management
contributes to preserving our
environment and making our region
more sustainable. Our landfills have
limited space, so waste diversion
is important.
WHAT'S HAPPENING Residential waste diversion has not
improved over the last five years.
GTA RESIDENTIAL WASTE DIVERSION 39% 2006 50% 2009 52% 2014 MULTI-UNIT RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS (MURBs) SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL HOMES such as apartment buildings and condos TEXTILES/CLOTHING ARE 95% RECYCLABLE and make up 10% of our garbage. More than two-thirds of what
people put in their garbage bags
could be diverted from landfill.
Waste 66% Divertible WHAT CAN WE DO? Improve waste reduction
options in MURBs
Improve recycling options
across the GTA

LAND USE

illustration of urban green space

As the population of our region continues to grow, managing the way we use our limited land becomes increasingly important.

We need to accommodate our growing population while also protecting our natural infrastructure and the services it provides. We need to create a more walkable, transit-oriented and self-sustaining region.

Better land use planning can improve traffic congestion, air quality and other quality of life dynamics, while also reducing water and energy waste, and preserving natural features.

illustration of urban farmland

In the GTA, the rate of urban sprawl has decreased and “green building” has increased since the last report card.  But farmland in the region continues to be lost, and the amount of greenspace per person has declined. The urban forest has limited diversity and has been affected by insect pests and extreme weather events.

To improve our regional sustainability, we need to build complete, compact and green communities, invest in green infrastructure, and strategically acquire, restore and protect greenspace and agricultural land.

 

AGRICULTURE We need to preserve our Farm land is where our food grows, and
is an important part of our local economy
and our cultural heritage.
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? WHAT'S HAPPENING? The amount of farm land in the
region continues to shrink as
development advances into our
rural areas.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Secure & protect farmland Research ways to integrate
agriculture into the urban
environment
shrinking farmland 239,000ha
2006 220,317ha
2011 7.8% LESS FARMLAND

GREEN BUILDINGS The GTA's green building Green buildings are designed to reduce the
impact on environment and human health
by efficiently using energy, water and other
resources.

One of the greatest benefits of green buildings
is their decreased energy use, which helps
reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? WHAT'S HAPPENING? Toronto region has the largest
and fastest growing green
building industry in Canada.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Establish municipal and provincial
green building policies
Require large buildings to publically
report energy & water consumption
sector is growing 48% of Toronto's greenhouse gas
emissions are generated by
buildings.
Despite the growth in green buildings,
they represent only a small fraction of all new
development in the region.
Results of Civic Action's Race to Reduce 12.1% energy reduction
in office buildings
4,200 cars off the road

GREENSPACE Greenspace needs to keep pace Plentiful greenspace makes urban areas more
livable, improves our health, and protects our
regional biodiversity.

Greenspace helps to improve air quality,
provide shade from UV radiation, muffle noise,
and keeps the city cool on hot summer days.
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? WHAT'S HAPPENING? The population continues to grow, but the
size and quality of the greenspace system is
not increasing at the same rate.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Protect, manage and fund our
greenspace system
Increase amount of greenspace
through land acquisitions
with the growing population 1.2 X INCREASE IN POPULATION While amount of greenspace did not significantly increase 2011 2015 $ Funding to manage community assets
is often not adequate to support the
greenspace system.

INTENSIFICATION Compact complete communities The population of the GTA
continues to grow rapidly and
we must accommodate this
growth in a sustainable way.
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? WHAT'S HAPPENING? The rate of expansion of the built-up area in the
GTA decreased in 2001-2011 compared to
1991-2001, suggesting that we have slowed the
rate of urban sprawl.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Build compact communities Improve transportation options are a key part of green living 86% of new residents (2001-2011) moved
into new communities at the edges of the
region, where there is limited public
transportation.
GTA POPULATION 10 5 0 1991 2001 2006 2011 2016 2021 2026 2031 2036 4.7M 6.6M 8.8M GTA EXPANSION RATE 26% 10% 1991-2001 2001-2011 Compact communities have high residential density with mixed
land uses. They have efficient, effective transit systems and
accessibility to local services and jobs. Compact communities
lessen the impact on the environment by reducing our
dependence on cars and the pollution we generate by travelling.

URBAN FOREST City trees provide vital The urban forest helps to:
Remove pollutants from the air and water
Reduce stormwater runoff
Cool communities and save energy
Improve our health and wellbeing
Provide recreation opportunities
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? WHAT'S HAPPENING? The GTA's urban forest is made up of mainly three types
of trees : maple, cedar and ash. This low diversity makes
it vulnerable to insect pests and disease. The invasive
pest the EMERALD ASH BORER is killing tens of
millions of trees across the province,
including many in the GTA. A changing
climate with more ice storms and
droughts can also weaken and
damage the urban forest.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Develop and champion policies that
protect and expand the urban forest
Expand municipal tree planting lists
to increase diversity
environmental services Studies show that residents have
significantly fewer health conditions
in city blocks with 10 or more trees.
The urban forest is a
critical component of our
green infrastructure.
= 34.2 MILLION trees in the GTA $14 BILLION to replace them

BIODIVERSITY

illustration of trees and birds

Biodiversity, the wide variety of living organisms and their ecosystems, provides us with irreplaceable services, like clean air and water, pollination of crops, and moderation of floods and storms.

Biodiversity is a reflection of ecosystem health, which is essential to our own health and well-being.

illustration of a robinIn the Toronto region, biodiversity is changing: tolerant stream fish seem to be replacing more sensitive species, and the biodiversity of native plants and animals appears to be declining.

These changes are largely due to the negative impacts from urbanization.

illustration of a salamanderImpacts from urbanization include stormwater runoff (altered water flow amounts, speeds and patterns), water pollution (including warm water), invasive species, and habitat loss and fragmentation.

To improve this aspect of environmental sustainability, we need to incorporate better stormwater management to help enhance water quality and flow, protect and restore coldwater streams, and strategically acquire, restore and protect more forest and wetland.

 

NATURAL COVER The quality of our natural cover Natural cover helps maintain
biodiversity. It also mitigates floods and
improves air quality.
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? WHAT'S HAPPENING? The quality of our natural cover
is declining.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Prioritize the protection of large
tracts of forest and wetland
Invest in restoring and managing
natural cover
is deteriorating TARGET: 17.8% 7.7% Forest & wetland habitat Larger patches of natural cover
support a wider range of native
plants and animals
NO COVER Meadow habitat } 25.5% of TRCA watersheds
is natural cover
30% NATURAL COVER
with a higher proportion of forest
and wetland
Impact of urbanization on
natural cover:
Water pollution
Soil compaction
Recreational pressures
Invasive species
Light and noise pollution

Biodiversity is an indicator of ecosystem
health. Every species depends on other
species to survive.
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? WHAT'S HAPPENING? Biodiversity scores for plants,
birds and frogs were similar for
this time period compared to
the last.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Strategically acquire, restore & protect
more forest and wetland
Improve local stewardship TERRESTRIAL BIODIVERSITY Development is reducing biodiversity across the region Yellow Spotted Salamander American Robin BIODIVERSITY Rural
Sites
Urban
Sites
poor fair excellent poor fair excellent Most sensitive bird species don't call the city "home" any longer. Sensitive forest bird
species found in
Sensitive forest bird
species found in
URBAN FOREST SITES RURAL FOREST SITES 8% 90% Threats to biodiversity include: Loss, damage and fragmentation
The invasion of non-native species
Pollution
Climate change
Stewardship programs engage local residents,
businesses, municipalities and conservation
authorities in on-the-ground projects that protect
and manage habitats and species diversity.

Fish biodiversity reflects the health of
our streams and lakes.
WHY IS THIS IMPORTANT? WHAT'S HAPPENING? Stormwater runoff is fast, warm and polluted.
In many parts of the GTA, stormwater flows
directly into streams.
WHAT CAN WE DO? Improve stormwater management Protect & restore coldwater streams FISH Pollution tolerant fish are taking over our waterways Sensitive stream fish such as
Redside Dace and Brook Trout
are found in fewer areas due
to urbanization.
STORMWATER Non-native, invasive fish can
devastate aquatic ecosystems.
Round Goby and Grass Carp have
been found in our waterways.
Fish biodiversity in Lake Ontario
is INCREASING
15 25 35 Fish Species Richness 1990 2015

Contributions From

Evergreen logo

Clean Air Partnership logo

Toronto Atmospheric Fund logo

OCAD logo

University of Toronto logo

Smart Prosperity Institute logo

WCCD logo

next practice logo sq

neptis logo

Playground illustration

Funding Provided By

york region logo

Region of Peel

City of Toronto logo